Manchester United and Newcastle: Combined XI Analysis

Manchester United will face Newcastle United on Boxing Day, marking the only Premier League match on this important date.

Both teams are aiming for Champions League qualification but need to close the gap in the top-four standings. Before their clash at Old Trafford, we have compiled a combined XI of Manchester United and Newcastle players, considering only those available for selection.

Manchester United vs Newcastle – Combined XI

Goalkeeper: Senne Lammens – Manchester United

Both teams’ goalkeepers have struggled recently, but Senne Lammens is chosen over Aaron Ramsdale. The Belgian started strong at Manchester United and shows promise, providing much-needed stability compared to last season.

Right-back: Tino Livramento – Newcastle

Eddie Howe has crafted a strong setup with Tino Livramento and Lewis Hall, making them one of the most effective full-back pairings in the league.

Centre-back: Malick Thiaw – Newcastle

Bringing Malick Thiaw to Newcastle for approximately £30 million has proven beneficial. The German has displayed excellent composure at centre-back and has even earned an international call-up.

Malick Thiaw strikes twice! ⚡️ pic.twitter.com/c5zIaZEVt5

— Newcastle United (@NUFC) November 29, 2025

Centre-back: Lisandro Martinez – Manchester United

With several defensive players missing, Lisandro Martinez’s return is a boost for Manchester United. The Argentine has the experience to guide a less seasoned team at Old Trafford and may even play in midfield, based on his recent performance.

Lisandro Martinez in central midfield (45 minutes):

100% aerial duels won
38 total touches
32 passes attempted
29 passes completed
5 passes into the final third
3 ball recoveries
1 shot

Is he an option moving forward? 🤔 pic.twitter.com/Ye0lEIkK4j

— Statman Dave (@StatmanDave) December 21, 2025

Left-back: Lewis Hall – Newcastle

The left-back position for England is competitive as the World Cup approaches, and Lewis Hall is making a strong case. His energy and delivery from the flanks stand out, ranking him among the best in tackles and progressive passes in the league.

Midfield: Bruno Guimaraes – Newcastle

Bruno Guimaraes is a vital asset for Newcastle, displaying his commitment and talent as the club progresses under new ownership. He is one of the most well-rounded midfielders in Europe, filling a gap that Manchester United needs to address.

Midfield: Sandro Tonali – Newcastle

Sandro Tonali further strengthens Newcastle’s dominance in our combined XI. He excels in various aspects of midfield play, showing resilience under pressure and possessing excellent passing skills.

Midfield: Joelinton – Newcastle

Joelinton is the powerhouse in Newcastle’s midfield, physically challenging opponents alongside Guimaraes and Tonali, presenting a significant challenge for Manchester United’s weakened midfield.

Forward: Matheus Cunha – Manchester United

Matheus Cunha was Manchester United’s first summer signing, joining after the club triggered his release clause at Wolves. He has recently regained form, scoring in consecutive matches and proving essential for the team.

2 in his last 2 Premier League matches.

Matheus Cunha is on fire! 👨‍🍳 pic.twitter.com/1urQ0dfJ7A

— Football on TNT Sports (@footballontnt) December 21, 2025

Forward: Anthony Gordon – Newcastle

Anthony Gordon is another player looking to secure a World Cup spot with England.

Forward: Nick Woltemade – Newcastle

Newcastle set a club record to sign Nick Woltemade as a replacement for Alexander Isak. He has impressed so far, scoring seven goals in 14 league matches, combining his height and agility effectively.

A brace for Nick Woltemade this afternoon 💪🇩🇪 pic.twitter.com/N5QhjLL8jG

— Newcastle United (@NUFC) December 20, 2025